About Us


Meet Oltremare Ristorante, Islamorada’s newest island eatery, where the flavors of Italy infuse the fresh Florida Keys seafood you love. We’re fans of farm-fresh ingredients, fresh-off-the-boat fish and wines that make you smile.

Whether you’re waking up with Meyer Lemon Ricotta Pancakes and espresso or winding down another beautiful day in Islamorada over a hearty Fisherman Stew and a bottle of chianti, Oltremare gives your favorite Italian a tropical twist you’ll want to share and savor. Open for all-day dining, as well as drinks and bar bites at Oltremare Ristorante Bar.


Sunday Brunch

Join us EVERY Sunday
for our Sinful Sunday Brunch,
featuring delicious plated
specialties and our soon to be
famous Bloody Mary cart

Martinis & Meatballs

Every Monday night we're pairing 5 mouthwatering craft martinis with
5 amazing meatball inspired dishes.
A match made in heaven!
Prices start at $8 per item

WINE DOWN WEDNESDAYS

New and unique wines normally sold by the bottle, offered by the glass. Wednesdays, 5:30p - 10p

Upcoming Events


Aged to Perfection - Cigar and Spirit Pairing

Friday, Feb. 5th, 7pm

Join us for an evening of fine spirits and cigars. This beachside gathering pairs cigar samplings with delicious dining from Oltremare Ristorante and a selection of bourbon, whiskey, and rums. Cigars provided by The Florida Keys' own Rodriguez Cigars.

$55 per person.

Brews on the Beach

Friday, March 4th

Oltremare teams up with Islamorada Beer Company for this enticing dinner on the beach, pairing delicious courses with local craft bee

Mangia with a Mentalist - featuring Bastille the Mentalist

February 12 & 13

Join us for dinner and a show and explore the amazing world of ESP. Dinner seating begins at 6:30pm. Showtime is 8pm.

$65, Chef's choice, 3 course dinner, and show to follow.

Cooking class with Chef Dario

2/23, 3/29 (Last Tuesday of each month)

Featuring delicious plated specialties and our famous Bloody Mary cart.

Sinful Sunday Brunch

Sundays, 11am - 3pm

Featuring delicious plated specialties and our famous Bloody Mary cart.

Martinis & Meatballs

Mondays, 5pm - 10pm

Pairing mouthwatering craft martinis with delectable meatball inspired dishes.

Wine Down Wednesdays

Wednesdays, 5:30pm - 10pm

New and unique wines normally sold by the bottle, offered by the glass.

FOLLOW @OLTREMARE_RISTORANTE

Hours of operation


Oltremare Ristorante
Breakfast 6:30am - 10:30am
Dinner 5:00pm - 10:00pm

Oltremare Bar 5:00pm - 12:00am

Oltremare at Amara Cay
80001 Overseas Highway
Islamorada, FL
(305) 664-0073
Hotel Marketing by Tambourine Hotel Marketing by Tambourine